I am a dog trainer as well as being involved in two agility clubs, all covered by the Kennel Pro policy so I am going to be hit with this situation three times! One club is all set until next fall; one club is up for renewal very soon, and I just decided to stick with Mourer-Foster and the Kennel Pro policy for my training business.
We are in NY. I did check into the RCNuccio a few years ago & they wouldn't cover NY.
I was in touch with Dennis at Mourer-Foster when my dog training insurance was canceled by CNA. He went over the new Hartford policy with me and answered every question- it appears to be the same as before, but higher levels of coverage and of course a higher price. He said CNA decided to get out of the dog training business because they weren't making any money on it. I had the option of another policy through Business Insurers of the Carolinas, and the new Kennel Pro policy still seems better, even with the price increase. They offer nicer payment plans, too, which the others didn't.
One of the things that I had to take into account was that regardless of the levels of coverage, Kennel Pro doesn't charge you for additional insureds. For my business, the cost of adding my additional insureds brought the BI policy up to the same price as the Kennel Pro.
When I mentioned the agility club renewal to Dennis, he didn't think there would be any problem with renewing it.
Of course, I haven't had to (knock on wood) make any claims, so I can't say how great any of the policies are at covering incidents.
It is sad to hear that the insurance industry is thinking that agility is a high risk. I'm going to hope that instructors start stepping up to better prepare their students for the trial situation so we can start changing that perception back to good!
Lynn Broderick